Savannah arrives at a remote house to deliver a pizza. The tall, expressionless customer, Richard, insists she come inside while he gets the payment, claiming he needs to verify her identity. Reluctantly, she enters, takes off her shoes at his request, and waits. When he calls her into an empty living room and then ignores her, a fed-up Savannah decides to leave.
Suddenly, Richard ambushes her, striking her with a baseball bat before pinning her to the floor and brutally choking her. Savannah fights desperately for her life, even faking unconsciousness to find a chance to escape, but Richard overpowers her. He mercilessly lifts her into the air by her throat. Despite her final pleas, Richard snaps her neck, killing her, and carries her lifeless body upstairs.
Afterward, Richard calmly eats a slice of the pizza. He then takes Savannah’s shoes and places them in a hidden drawer filled with shoes from previous victims. He labels her pair "Savannah Pizza Girl," adding her to his gruesome trophy collection.